By David Gray Carlson

This ebook constitutes an important development within the examine of Hegelian philosophy by way of delivering the 1st complete observation at the enormous The technological know-how of common sense, Hegel's vital paintings which informs some other undertaking Hegel ever undertook. the writer has devised a procedure for diagramming each logical transition that Hegel makes, a lot of that have by no means ahead of been explored in English. This finds a startling organizational subtlety in Hegel's paintings which heretofore has long gone ignored. during charting Hegel's logical growth, the writer presents a lively defence and thorough explication of unheard of scale and scope. The booklet covers the complete diversity of matters hooked up with The technology of common sense corresponding to Being, Essence, degree, Subjectivity and God, displaying how Hegel used good judgment to make transitions from one class to the subsequent. The e-book additionally mediates Hegel's disagreement with Kant, whose Critique of natural cause is Hegel's significant pageant in metaphysical systemization. Any pupil encountering The technological know-how of common sense, probably the main tricky and by means of a long way the main lucrative of Hegel's philosophical works, will locate in Carlson's e-book a useful significant other to their learn.

Show description

Read Online or Download A Commentary to Hegel's Science of Logic PDF

Similar logic books

Logic colloquium '90: Proc. Helsinki 1990

This quantity is the lawsuits of common sense Colloquium ninety held in Helsinki, Finland, from July 15 to July 22, 1990. The congress belongs to the once a year sequence of the eu summer time conferences of the organization for Symbolic common sense. those lawsuits include thirteen examine papers written almost always by means of the invited audio system of the congress.

Innovative Technological Materials: Structural Properties by Neutron Scattering, Synchrotron Radiation and Modeling

This booklet presents firstly principles at the solutions that neutrons and Synchrotron Radiation may possibly provide in cutting edge fabrics technological know-how and expertise. specifically, non-conventional, strange or leading edge neutron and x-ray scattering experiments (from either the medical and the instrumental perspective) may be defined which both have novel functions or offer a brand new perception into fabric technology and expertise.

Additional resources for A Commentary to Hegel's Science of Logic

Sample text

Id. at 158; see also 188,198. Instead, the SL is supposed to be organized by "a sidelong glance at the history of philosophy," Id. at 284. Such a position denies that Hegel has written a Logic. In my view, Hegel intended the very "ritualistic three-step" that Kaufmann denies. " (384) At this point Hegel signals a fundamental shift in the attitude of the Understanding. Starting with chapter 10, the Understanding contemplates what is not. 26 Quality To summarize, the Borromean knot represents Logic as a circle com­ prised of circles, in accord with Hegel's comment from the EL: Each of the parts of philosophy is a philosophical whole, a circle rounded and complete in itself.

Some take the above passage to be a legitimate move of the Logic - in effect, simply a restatement of the principle that one should start with Pure Immediacy. MAKER, supra note 7, at 73-4; WlNFIELD, supra note 5, at 31. Rather than viewing the true commencement of the Logic as the one-sided proposition of the Understanding, Winfield thinks that determinacy arises for no reason: One could thus say that the proper answer to the question "Why is there determinacy? is that there is and can be no reason, for any attempt to assign one presupposes determinacy by treating indeterminacy as if it were a definite determiner.

27 Errol Harris considers the accusation of Adolph Trendelenburg, a 19th century critic: Hegel smuggled "time" into the system along with Becoming. Harris acquits Hegel Being-Nothing-Becoming 17 Nevertheless, the very idea of negation refers to a past. If I say that Being is not, I am also saying Being once was, because negation always works on some positive entity that preceded it. As we shall soon discover, Dialectical Reason remembers, and so Logic entails sequence, a kind of fantasy time - not to be confused with chronological time.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.16 of 5 – based on 13 votes